If I was going to list everything we knew for sure about the brain,
it would be a very, very long list. Instead of trying to do that, I am
going to focus on things we know relevant to my last post, which was
quite negative about the new "brain mapping" initiative, and which generated a lot of
criticism
(http://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/fixing-psychology/201304/why-brain-mapping-is-stupid-idea). The title of the post then, should maybe be less “What do we know about the brain?”
and more “What are some first principles we can use to understand how
the brain operates?”
Tuesday, April 16, 2013
Friday, April 5, 2013
Why the Brain Mapping project is a Stupid Idea
It was just announced that President
Obama wants to start spending one hundred million dollars to "map the
brain", and that his oft-times rival Eric Cantor thinks it’s a great idea.
But it is a terrible idea, because I can tell you, right now, about half of the
big lessons they will learn. Plus, for about a million dollars, I could probably gather a
group of experts together to tell you about half of what remains. I'm not sure
what, exactly, would be left after that, but I'm sure it would be comparatively
cheap to figure out.
Labels:
brain,
developmental psychobiology,
embodied cognition,
fixing psychology,
minds,
neuroscience,
perception-action cycles
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)